So, when I implemented ore generation for my mod, everything's working as expected, except, that my tin ore is a lot rarer than I intended. Not big issue, I thought, then proceeded to bump up the value for vein per chunk. To my surprise, that didn't help, no matter how absurd I altered the value to. But in the end of the day, the ore still generated, so I called it a day and continued working on other stuff.

Only today, when I was working on new ores, I discovered that the tin ores are generating in abundance down in y=-40. This made me slowly realise where the issue lie.

    public static final Holder<PlacedFeature> TIN_ORE_PLACED = PlacementUtils.register("tin_ore_placed",
            ModConfiguredFeatures.TIN_ORE, commonOrePlacement(32, 
                    HeightRangePlacement.triangle(VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(-16), VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(94))));

    public static final Holder<PlacedFeature> TIN_ORE_LARGE_PLACED = PlacementUtils.register("tin_ore_large_placed",
            ModConfiguredFeatures.TIN_ORE_LARGE, commonOrePlacement(16,
                    HeightRangePlacement.triangle(VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(-16), VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(94))));

Here in this section of my ModPlacedFeatured.java, I think I misunderstood the 'VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom' value, I thought it means my ore will only generate between y=-16 to y=94, and will be most commonly found in the y=39 region. However, it is evident that the tin ores are more commonly generated in y=-40 and below, despite the fact they shouldn't be there in the first place. 

In an attempt to un-mess up my mess up, I tried to look into what the VerticalAnchor value is for, and did a range of research online. I searched blindly for what I will not find.

This is my final desperate cry for help.

Edit: Changing the aboveBottom to absolute fixed it, huge thanks

Edited January 11, 20232 yr by RuthlessNail

Quote

VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(-16)

So -16 blocks "above" the bottom of the world. Or in other words, in the void beneath the world. -64 - 16 = -80

Quote

VerticalAnchor.aboveBottom(94)

-64 + 94 = 30

Since it is a triangle, the peak will be at the middle of the range (30 - 80) / 2 = -25

 

Perhaps you meant to use VertialAnchor.absolute() ? Or -16 to 94 with a peak at (94 - 16) / 2 = 39

10 minutes ago, warjort said:

So -16 blocks "above" the bottom of the world. Or in other words, in the void beneath the world. -64 - 16 = -80

-64 + 94 = 30

Since it is a triangle, the peak will be at the middle of the range (30 - 80) / 2 = -25

 

Perhaps you meant to use VertialAnchor.absolute() ? Or -16 to 94 with a peak at (94 - 16) / 2 = 39

Thanks mate, that makes total sense, I'll test it out right now and see if it works.