No wheat seed dropping ?

[olfgrond]

Hi everybody,

 

I started multiple world with Minecraft 1.13.2 & Forge 25.0.141/147/149/191 and wheat seed doesn't drop from regular and tall grass.

 

Any idea ?

 

Thx,

 

Olfgrond

[olfgrond]

Hi,

 

After 2 hours playing on a new map, i reached to drop two of them. It seems that the drop rate change after deploying Forge.

 

Olfgrond

Edited April 26, 2019 by olfgrond

[silvervtx05]

I noticed the same.  So this is a Forge issue?  

[silvervtx05]

Just tried an earlier version of forge with 1.13.2 and it was slightly better but very obvious an issue with wheat seed drops.

Version 1.13.2

Forger 25.0.74

[silvervtx05]

Latest Forge version 1.13.2-25.0.209 still has not addressed the Wheat Seed issue.  Anyone else seeing this?

[quadraxis]

Known issue, see https://github.com/MinecraftForge/MinecraftForge/issues/5675. Possibly waiting on a better system in https://github.com/MinecraftForge/MinecraftForge/pull/5497, or in 1.14, although the currently broken hooks should probably be removed to restore vanilla behaviour in the meantime.

[Sana36]

Tall grass was still dropping at normal rate, last I checked. But yes it is known and won't be fixed in 1.13x Forge.

[silvervtx05]

Not fixing in 1.13.x....bummer.  I love Forge!  

[Sana36]

I love Forge too, which is why I started helping.

 

As I understand it, the idea was not to make any changes which would have to be undone for 1.14.x and therefore, hopefully, make it quicker for forge 1.14.x to be released.

[LexManos]

Interesting, seems to of slipped through the cracks. With 1.13.2 being a transitional version and 1.14 right around the corner im not gunna spend to much time on this as it should be moot with 1.14's changes.

May be worth just nuking our patches related to this in 1.13.2 to keep vanilla compatibility.

[Sana36]

It is fine to test the world but there are limits on how many times to say the same thing.

PR 5485, 5675 & 5434

[LexManos]

No idea what you're saying, but as a temporary fix for 1.13 until we remove it in 1.14 I added the vanilla entry to the seed list.

[Sana36]

Inconsistencies, make it hard to help:

1. When 'helping' on the forum following the rules as I know it, answering simple questions or reminding people to post logs in a certain way. The someone more senior comes along and helps anyway. Change it from a rule to a guideline or something and then let us all know, maybe by posting it in writing somewhere.

 

2. Testing forge. Being involved in reporting issues found during testing, 1.13.x was frustrating. The grass seed one was mentioned multiple times from very early and nothing happened. The beta was released with almost no mobs and one or maybe two people commented. You want more testers, ones that actually notice when no land based mobs spawn, help make the feed back process work. Decide where they need to be reported and come up with a label or format that makes the most of their value and allows others to add their tests of the same issue.

 

3. Generally knowing what is going on with development of Forge, I found out most of what I knew from comments in obscure PRs. The link to your document in the header on the forum is a great idea but also think of a less technical, more player oriented version that can be copy and pasted to answer any questions about 1.14.x.