Please read the rules and FAQ before starting a new topic

[Reactivated] [1.9]V.1780: Can't open chest even with UPPER slab/REVERSED stairs

Posted March 21, 20169 yr

Using version 1.9-forge1.9-12.16.0.1780:

(issue existed several version before this).

If put stairs block or slab block on top of a chest (only tested double chest). the chest cannot be opened regardless what position I put the slab (top/ bottom), stairs (facing up/down)

Launch vanilla 1.9 and this issue goes away. Also tried without mods installed (just forge 1.9) and same issue.

The log fml-client-latest.log: http://pastebin.com/U18qHJyB

Thanks and keep up the good work.

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

I believe this is intentional, see this thread and the threads linked in it.

Please don't PM me to ask for help. Asking your question in a public thread preserves it for people who are having the same problem in the future.

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

Author

thanks if this is intentional I will consider this problem closed. small price to pay for awesome mods to gain with forge

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

Author

More testing with this, it seems this issue is a bit different, from the link you sent out, regardless how I position the slab/stairs, the chest would not open

See this picture (borrowed from the other thread), chests cannot open in all the ABCD positions. I will "reactivate" this bug for now until being told its by design otherwise.

http://i.imgur.com/EksijWN.jpg

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

As mentioned that is intentional.

Don't care, Mojang is wrong, we will continue to fix this bug. Not fixing it would require us to special case the shit out of all stairs, or break a lot of Forge/Mod/Vanilla features.

The bug being mentioned is this one, which states that chests opening with slabs, stairs, etc over them is a bug. And while Mojang says its not a bug, Lex, not wanting to do more coding work than needed, is deciding to treat it as a bug.

So this means Forge will continue to make it so chests cannot be opened when slabs, stairs, etc are over them.

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

As mentioned that is intentional.

Don't care, Mojang is wrong, we will continue to fix this bug. Not fixing it would require us to special case the shit out of all stairs, or break a lot of Forge/Mod/Vanilla features.

The bug being mentioned is this one, which states that chests opening with slabs, stairs, etc over them is a bug. And while Mojang says its not a bug, Lex, not wanting to do more coding work than needed, is deciding to treat it as a bug.

So this means Forge will continue to make it so chests cannot be opened when slabs, stairs, etc are over them.

But as Lex mentioned in this thread, chests are only supposed to check if the bottom of the block is solid. Placing a slab in the upper half of a block or upside-down stairs shouldn't prevent chests from opening.

Please don't PM me to ask for help. Asking your question in a public thread preserves it for people who are having the same problem in the future.

Quote

March 21, 20169 yr

But as Lex mentioned in this thread, chests are only supposed to check if the bottom of the block is solid.

Ah, didn't see that post.

Quote

March 22, 20169 yr

Yes the behavior is bugged in 1.9, due to a change it's been fixed. I forgot to put a UP check in one if statement.

Again, SOLID surfaces BLOCK CHESTS.

This is simply how the world works.

Vanilla being BUGGY and having a half-assed side-solid system IS A BUG.

It does not make logical sense.

We have fix this bug for ages, and in doing so it enables a lot of special mod features like microblocks/covers/special placements.

I do Forge for free, however the servers to run it arn't free, so anything is appreciated.
Consider supporting the team on Patreon

Quote

March 22, 20169 yr

Author

You are awesome! thanks and keep up the marvelous work!

Quote

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.

Reply to this topic...

https://forums.minecraftforge.net/topic/37304-reactivated-19v1780-cant-open-chest-even-with-upper-slabreversed-stairs/

Followers

Go to topic listing

IPS spam blocked by CleanTalk.

Announcements

How to change player renderer and transform model parts?

I have been trying for a while now to make a custom player renderer, and replace the vanilla player renderer with it. So far I've come up with a custom player renderer class that extends vanilla PlayerRenderer:
package com.FireDude123.BOTW.entity.renderer; import com.mojang.blaze3d.vertex.PoseStack; import net.minecraft.client.player.AbstractClientPlayer; import net.minecraft.client.renderer.MultiBufferSource; import net.minecraft.client.renderer.entity.player.PlayerRenderer; import net.minecraft.client.renderer.entity.EntityRendererProvider; import net.minecraftforge.client.event.RenderPlayerEvent; import net.minecraftforge.common.MinecraftForge; public class PoseablePlayerRenderer extends PlayerRenderer { public PoseablePlayerRenderer(EntityRendererProvider.Context ctx, boolean slim) { super(ctx, slim); System.out.println("here too"); } @Override public void render(AbstractClientPlayer p_117788_, float p_117789_, float p_117790_, PoseStack poseStack, MultiBufferSource p_117792_, int p_117793_) { System.out.println("didnt get here lol"); model.leftArm.xRot=(float)Math.toRadians(160); super.render(p_117788_, p_117789_, p_117790_, poseStack, p_117792_, p_117793_); } } As you can see, the intended purpose of this is to raise the player's left arm by 160 degrees. However, combined with this logic in ClientModEvents:
@Mod.EventBusSubscriber(modid = MODID, bus = Mod.EventBusSubscriber.Bus.MOD, value = Dist.CLIENT) public static class ClientModEvents { @SubscribeEvent public static void onClientSetup(FMLClientSetupEvent event) { EntityRenderers.register((EntityType<? extends AbstractClientPlayer>)(EntityType<?)EntityType.PLAYER, ctx -> new PoseablePlayerRenderer(ctx, true)); EntityRenderers.register(Entities.MAGNESIS_BLOCK.get(), com.FireDude123.BOTW.entity.renderer.BlockDisplayRenderer::new); EntityRenderers.register(Entities.REMOTE_BOMB.get(), ThrownItemRenderer::new); EntityRenderers.register(Entities.CRYONIS_ICE.get(), com.FireDude123.BOTW.entity.renderer.BlockDisplayRenderer::new); EntityRenderers.register(Entities.STASIS_BLOCK.get(), FallingBlockRenderer::new); } @SubscribeEvent public static void registerLayerDefinitions(EntityRenderersEvent.RegisterLayerDefinitions event) { event.registerLayerDefinition(new ModelLayerLocation(new ResourceLocation(BOTW.MODID, "paraglider"), "main"), ParagliderLayer::createBodyLayer); } }(I also have a paraglider layer here for something else, it's working perfectly fine, also I used the slim setting because the player is slim in 1.20.1 forge)
This logic isn't replacing the renderer, as far as I can tell. Can someone please advise as to why, and how to fix it?

By FireDude123 · Posted 22 hours ago22 hr
How to add my mob to another mod's biome in 1.20.1.

I'm on 1.20.1 and was wondering if there was a way to add a mob I am going to make to a other mod's biome (Regions Unexplored in this case). I am trying to figure this out before I start coding the mod. Could someone point me to a good guide on this? I saw some things about biome modifier's but all the resources are either to short, unhelpful or for a different version. Thanks in advance. (i am a beginner but i have java and modding knowledge so this isn't like a "i am new and don't know anything about coding" problem btw)

By ilov3gam3z · Posted Yesterday at 04:08 PM1 day
Help with file conversion

Many Forge users seek help with file conversions. Similarly, managing your health can benefit from structured tools like the https://wellness-app.com/calculator/fasting-calculator/ and a free intermittent fasting calculator. These tools help you plan and personalize your fasting and eating windows based on your lifestyle and goals. By entering your preferred fasting duration and meal times, you receive a tailored schedule that makes intermittent fasting easier to follow. Just as mastering file conversions improves modding success, using a fasting calculator brings clarity and structure to your health routine, supporting better results over time.

By Brialeblanc · Yesterday at 10:34 AM1 day
Cobblemon invalid player data

Hi everyone, I keep getting "invalid player data" when trying to log onto my friend's server. Log analysis says to remove Night Lights and ImmediatelyFast, but that doesn't work. Any insight is appreciated

Log: https://mclo.gs/uj6pMkd

By CobbleDN · Posted Yesterday at 04:14 AM1 day
Bad pathfinding for big mobs (1.21.1)

I've struggled with this for way too long now, so I have decided to ask for some assistance here because there is almost no information about this online.

I made a hostile mob and I built it like this:
public static final Supplier<EntityType<Bunyip>> BUNYIP = ENTITY_TYPES.register("bunyip" , () -> EntityType.Builder. of(Bunyip::new, MobCategory.MONSTER).sized(3f, 2.5f).eyeHeight(1.75f).build("bunyip"));

However, I have discovered that a BoundingBox of 3 is too big for the vanilla pathfinding to work well. In fact, anything bigger than a block will not work well. This is especially noticeable when having it chase a player in a negative X and/or negative Z direction. The mob starts spinning, walking backwards, walking diagonally, etc.

I am using the Goal system:
protected void registerGoals() { super.registerGoals(); this.goalSelector.addGoal(1, new MeleeAttackGoal(this, 1.25, true)); this.targetSelector.addGoal(2, new NearestAttackableTargetGoal<>(this, Player.class, true, true)); }

This does not seem to be a me issue as the ravager, one of the biggest vanilla mobs, also struggles with proper pathfinding. I am a bit familiar with how Minecraft's pathfinding works, but not enough to make a pathfinding system from scratch (or at least not in a reasonable amount of time). Is there any way to fix this with some tweaks or will I have to make a custom pathfinding system?

By VictorEvers · Posted Tuesday at 08:42 PM2 days

There are no registered users currently online

Sign In

[Reactivated] [1.9]V.1780: Can't open chest even with UPPER slab/REVERSED stairs

Featured Replies

Join the conversation

Posts

How to change player renderer and transform model parts?

How to add my mob to another mod's biome in 1.20.1.

Help with file conversion

Cobblemon invalid player data

Bad pathfinding for big mobs (1.21.1)

Who's Online (See full list)

Important Information

Account

Navigation

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)

Chrome (Desktop)

Safari (iOS 16.4+)

Safari (macOS)

Edge (Android)

Edge (Desktop)

Firefox (Android)

Firefox (Desktop)