[1.9.4] [SOLVED] Entity movement lags

[Bektor]

Hi,

 

I've got some huge problems with my entity. It just "lags" when moving. So you can see that it moves, stops and then starts moving again.

 

                EntityMy my= (EntityMy ) entity;
                
                double speed = (double)((this.getSize() + my.getSize()) * 5.5f);
                if(distanceSqrt < speed && distanceSqrt > .1d) {
                    this.motionX += -moveX / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                    this.motionY += -moveY / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                    this.motionZ += -moveZ / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                } 

This is the code for the movement. It is part of the moveNearbyEntity() method which handles all movement of surrounding entities and the

entity itself.

 

And in the update method I'm calling this:

        this.moveNearbyEntity();
        if(this.motionX != .0d || this.motionY != .0d || this.motionZ != .0d) {
            this.motionX *= .6d;
            this.motionY *= .6d;
            this.motionZ *= .6d;
            super.moveEntity(this.motionX, this.motionY, this.motionZ);
        }

 

Here is the part where I get the moveXYZ and distanceSqr values:

            double moveX = (this.posX + .5d) - (entity.posX + .5d);
            double moveY = (this.posY + .5d) - (entity.posY + .5d);
            double moveZ = (this.posZ + .5d) - (entity.posZ + .5d);
            
            double distanceSqrt = Math.sqrt(moveX * moveX + moveY * moveY + moveZ * moveZ);

It is done with the entity object and not the my object because it's used for all movement. And modifying the movement of other entities works fine with that code.

 

So what am I doing wrong?

 

Thx in advance.

Bektor

[Alexthe666]

Either:

1. You are moving it too fast

2. you registered it with a low velocity rate

 

could we see where you registered it?

[Bektor]

EntityRegistry.registerModEntity(EntityMy.class, "My", 0, PrimevalForest.instance, 150, 3, true, 0x000001, 0x00ff0f);

 

EntityMy extends Entity

 

Oh and it's not moving really fast. I can move faster.

[Alexthe666]

Your velocity updates is 3. To give you perspective, a squid has 10 and an arrow has 20. Your tracking range is 150, and a normal vanilla mob's is 80.

[Bektor]

  On 6/4/2016 at 3:32 PM, Alexthe666 said:

Your velocity updates is 3. To give you perspective, a squid has 10 and an arrow has 20. Your tracking range is 150, and a normal vanilla mob's is 80.

Even with the values 20 for velocity updates  and 80 for tracking range it is so "laggy".

[horsewithnoname]

  On 6/4/2016 at 3:13 PM, Bektor said:

Hi,

 

I've got some huge problems with my entity. It just "lags" when moving. So you can see that it moves, stops and then starts moving again.

 

                EntityMy my= (EntityMy ) entity;
                
                double speed = (double)((this.getSize() + my.getSize()) * 5.5f);
                if(distanceSqrt < speed && distanceSqrt > .1d) {
                    this.motionX += -moveX / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                    this.motionY += -moveY / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                    this.motionZ += -moveZ / distanceSqrt / (double) speed * (my.getSize() / 75.d);
                } 

This is the code for the movement. It is part of the moveNearbyEntity() method which handles all movement of surrounding entities and the

entity itself.

 

And in the update method I'm calling this:

        this.moveNearbyEntity();
        if(this.motionX != .0d || this.motionY != .0d || this.motionZ != .0d) {
            this.motionX *= .6d;
            this.motionY *= .6d;
            this.motionZ *= .6d;
            super.moveEntity(this.motionX, this.motionY, this.motionZ);
        }

 

Here is the part where I get the moveXYZ and distanceSqr values:

            double moveX = (this.posX + .5d) - (entity.posX + .5d);
            double moveY = (this.posY + .5d) - (entity.posY + .5d);
            double moveZ = (this.posZ + .5d) - (entity.posZ + .5d);
            
            double distanceSqrt = Math.sqrt(moveX * moveX + moveY * moveY + moveZ * moveZ);

It is done with the entity object and not the my object because it's used for all movement. And modifying the movement of other entities works fine with that code.

 

So what am I doing wrong?

 

Thx in advance.

Bektor

 

Are you performing these operations (setting new motion) on server, on client, or on both? I encountered similar problem, try moving this logic (setting motion) on server.

[Bektor]

Everything is performed server-side.

[Bektor]

Any ideas what's wrong?

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 3:53 PM, diesieben07 said:

If you modify the motion server side then yes, it's gonna be a big jaggy.

But why is it so?

I mean the server has to send the changes to the client and not the client to the server. Then every entity could move in a different direction on a server. So PlayerA sees the Entity moving south while PlayerB sees the entity moving north --> Server should handle entity movement.

 

I mean, it makes no sense....

And even when I do it client side, I still have to send a custom packet to the client which tells that the entity motion should changed.

EDIT: And isn't the movement of other entities in Minecraft also done server-side?

[Draco18s]

Movement is calculated both client side and server side, provided that the mobs are making the same decisions.

 

Why?

 

Because the server is in control, but the update frequency and packet delay results in laggy, disjointed movement.

So it's calculated on the client too for interpolation.

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 4:14 PM, Draco18s said:

Movement is calculated both client side and server side, provided that the mobs are making the same decisions.

 

Why?

 

Because the server is in control, but the update frequency and packet delay results in laggy, disjointed movement.

So it's calculated on the client too for interpolation.

So what need I to do to get it working correctly on my mod?

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 4:58 PM, diesieben07 said:

Do it on both sides.

So I have to send a packet to the client with the values and in the onMessage method I have to apply them to the motion value?

 

EDIT: if I would know how to get access to the entity in a packet

[Bektor]

So how can I do that?

(Currently the complete logic part is done in the onUpdate() method and a method which get's called by the onUpdate() method.

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 5:21 PM, diesieben07 said:

Make the client apply the motion... just like the server.

Yeah, but how can I tell the client to apply the motion without sending packets?

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 5:31 PM, diesieben07 said:

How does the server know when to apply the motion?

hm, no idea. I just have the onUpdate method and add a value to the motion, then multiply it by .8 and call super.moveEntity().

And add only motion when the boolean in the if statement is true, so when a specific entity is nearby.

[Bektor]

Yes. Just the checks for the nearby entities aren't every tick.

[Bektor]

  On 6/5/2016 at 5:48 PM, diesieben07 said:

Do the same on the client then...

How?

[Bektor]

Well, on the server I'm doing this all in the entity class itself.

[Bektor]

Well, it changes that I don't know how to do it, because the onUpdate method will do it on the server-side, otherwhise it would work.

And sending packets does MC Vanilla already.

[Bektor]

Then it should already be called on the client. (Well, it would even not make then sense that for player movement I have to send a packet)

[Bektor]

---