[1.10+] Is it necessary to put modid in unlocalized name?

[MrBendelScrolls]

Do I have to put modid in unlocalized name of an item? Would there be any conflicts if I don't?

For example:

this.setUnlocalizedName("name")
this.setUnlocalizedName(modid + ".name")

I find the second line in many tutorials, but I don't really think it's necessary.

Edited June 20, 2017 by MrBendelScrolls
Missing brace

[Choonster]

It's not absolutely required, but it's a good idea to avoid potential conflicts. All unlocalised names are used as keys in the same Map, so your unlocalised name's translation could overwrite or be overwritten by the same name from another mod.

 

I recommend using the Item's registry name (IForgeRegistryEntry#getRegistryName) as the unlocalised name as it already includes the mod ID.

Edited June 20, 2017 by Choonster

[Alexiy]

It only matters when some other mod happens to have same translation key as in your mod. Chance of this depends on an amount of mods played (still low chance in my opinion).

[loordgek]

6 hours ago, Alexiy said:

still low chance in my opinion

a chance is a chance how small it is.

if things break w/ other mods you will have a hard time tracking it down