Jump to content
Currently supported: All versions

How to use Forge and ModLoader at the same time

FEarBG

By FEarBG
in General Discussion

 Share

Recommended Posts

FEarBG Tree Puncher

FEarBG

Posted
Posted

First, I know that Forge have FML which should replace ModLoader and this is why Forge can now work independently without him.

 

The problem is that FML can not replace ModLoader really ..

 

Already come across at least 10 mods that need ModLoader and can not work with Forge.

 

So now I need to have ModLoader and Forge together in my minecraft.jar if I want to use all my mods.

 

Sure, but they use the same classes. Who should install second, so he can overwrite files ? Is there another way to use them both without creating conflict with one another ?

OvermindDL1 World Shaper

OvermindDL1

Posted
Posted

They will *NOT* work together.

If there is a mod that works on ML but does not work on FML, then as per the big giant red words on the front page, post links to the mods and your forgemodloader log, as the big red text says.

hotrods20 Creeper Killer

hotrods20

Posted
Posted

Might I also say that you should make sure it isn't 2 mods that conflict and not Forge/ModLoader.  Forge is compatible with all the mods I have tried.  Did you read the errors it produced or did you just assume it was Forge's fault?  If the error said anything along the lines of conflicting IDs, then your mods don't play friendly.  Simple as that.

width=320 height=64http://www.slothygaming.com/img/ota.png[/img]

If your grammar is shit and you blatantly don't know what you're doing, I will not help you.

FEarBG Tree Puncher

FEarBG

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Ok, my bad...

 

The only problem with Forge is that he have a little more *. classes then ModLoader. And because of them sometime there is a mod who is using the same classes. Like "Render Player API" who is using "we.class" which is also included in Forge.

 

We have the same deal with "OptiFine" and "Forge"... If I install Forge after some of those mods, things go bad ..

 

ModLoader don't have those classes and that's why he is easy to use and work immediately.

 

About my 10 mods problem, it seems that everything was working as a chain starting from "Render Player API" and "OptiFine" problem..

LexManos Reality Controller

LexManos

Posted
Posted

Forge edits a lot of things so that other mods don't.

Any other mod that edits base classes is doing it wrong. There is very little reason for any mod out there to edit a base class.

Just because ML doesn't edit as many doesn't mean it is anywhere near the power or compatibility Forge/FML offers.

Anyways, simple answer is you do not use ML and Forge together, it will not work.

However, all ML mods should world perfectly fine with Forge as long as they do not edit base classes.

I do Forge for free, however the servers to run it arn't free, so anything is appreciated.
Consider supporting the team on Patreon

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

脳   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

脳   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

脳   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

脳   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

脳
 Share
Go to topic listing

Announcements



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • GPGPGold9393
      Death screen only shows the "You Died!" part

      By GPGPGold9393 路 Posted

      The problem occurs also in 1.20.1 Forge, but with an "Error executing task on client" instead. I have "Sinytra Connector" installed. On 1.21.5 Fabric, there is no problem. When this happens, the chat message before the death screen appears gets sent, with an extra dash added.
    • collinj153
      Can't get custom sounds to play. MC 1.19.2.

      By collinj153 路 Posted

      Well, as usual, it was user error. Naming mismatch in sounds.json.  Please delete this post if you find it necessary. 
    • collinj153
      Can't get custom sounds to play. MC 1.19.2.

      By collinj153 路 Posted

      Hello Forge community.  I'm running into an issue with a mod I'm working on.  To preface, I can call /playsound modId:name music @a and I can hear the sound I registered being played in game. Great!  However, I cannot get it to trigger via my mod code.    Registration: public static final RegistryObject<SoundEvent> A_WORLD_OF_MADNESS = SOUND_EVENTS.register("a_world_of_madness", () -> new SoundEvent(new ResourceLocation("tetheredsouls", "a_world_of_madness")));   Playback: Minecraft mc = Minecraft.getInstance(); if (!(mc.player instanceof LocalPlayer) || mc.level == null) return; LocalPlayer player = (LocalPlayer) mc.player; BlockPos pos = player.blockPosition(); SoundEvent track = ModSounds.A_WORLD_OF_MADNESS.get(); System.out.println(track); System.out.println(pos); System.out.println(player); // play exactly like the tutorial: client-only, at the player's position try { mc.level.playLocalSound( player.getX(), player.getY(), player.getZ(), track, SoundSource.MUSIC, // Or MASTER if needed 1f, 1f, false ); System.out.println("[DEBUG] playSound success: " + track.getLocation()); } catch (Exception e) { System.err.println("[ERROR] Failed to play sound: " + track.getLocation()); e.printStackTrace(); } Sounds.json:   { "theme_of_laura": { "category": "music", "sounds": [ { "name": "tetheredsouls:a_world_of_madness", "stream": true } ] } } Things I have tried: - multiple .ogg files. Short .ogg files (5 seconds, <100KB).  - default minecraft sounds imported from import net.minecraft.sounds.SoundEvents; These work given my code. No idea why these are different.  - playSound() method, as well as several others in past iterations that did not work   I would be forever grateful if somebody could point me in the right direction. I've looked at several mod github repositories and found extremely similar code to what I'm doing. I've also found several threads in this forum that did not solve my issue. I just cannot figure out what I'm doing differently, and why I'm able to queue sounds manually with playsound but the code won't play it (despite confirming the code is being run with the debug statements.)
    • mochi957640
      ROPL

      By mochi957640 路 Posted

      馃榾
    • TileEntity
      exception in server time loop

      By TileEntity 路 Posted

      Delete the tensura-reincarnated/common.toml file (config folder)

  • Topics

脳
脳
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.

  I accept